Shipping Estimate
USA
- USA
- CAN
- USA
- CAN
Ships within 48 hours · Estimated delivery Jul 12 - Jul 17
For Your Every Summer RSVP, with Code: SUMMER15
Description
potted succulent plants for sale Cotyledon Papillaris Choco LineDescription Light Soil Water Hardiness Cotyledon 'Papillaris Choco Line' is a distinctive succulent with unusual leaf texture and muted, earthy colors. A hybrid member of the Crassulaceae family, it likely shares ancestry with species native to South Africa, where Cotyledons evolved to thrive in dry, rocky environments. 'Choco Line' forms a compact, low growing shape with thick, fleshy leaves covered in a soft layer of fine hairs, giving the plant a
-
Cotyledon 'Papillaris Choco Line' is a distinctive succulent with unusual leaf texture and muted, earthy colors. A hybrid member of the Crassulaceae family, it likely shares ancestry with species native to South Africa, where Cotyledons evolved to thrive in dry, rocky environments. 'Choco Line' forms a compact, low-growing shape with thick, fleshy leaves covered in a soft layer of fine hairs, giving the plant a velvety feel. Its subtle beauty makes it a good choice for small containers, rock gardens, and detailed succulent arrangements.
The leaves of Papillaris Choco Line are plump, oval to slightly paddle-shaped, and tend to grow close together, creating dense, tidy rosettes. They typically appear in shades of muted green to bluish-green, often tinged with chocolate-brown or reddish edges, especially when exposed to bright light or cooler temperatures. Tiny, soft projections (papillae) on the leaf surface give the plant a lightly textured appearance, especially when viewed up close. Mature plants stay relatively small, usually reaching 6 to 10 inches tall and spreading slowly over time.
Cotyledon species stand apart from other succulents like Echeveria or Sedum due to their woolly, protective coatings and slightly more shrub-like growth. While many succulents prefer intense sun, Cotyledons often do better with partial sun or filtered light, especially in hot climates. Their fleshy leaves are designed to store moisture efficiently, but the fine hairs also help minimize evaporation and protect against sunburn. Some Cotyledon species produce bell-shaped flowers on tall stalks, although Papillaris Choco Line is mostly grown for its foliage and may flower only rarely in cultivation.
Because of its compact size and interesting surface texture, Cotyledon 'Papillaris Choco Line' fits well into mixed succulent gardens or as a subtle accent in minimalist plant displays. It adds a soft, tactile element to succulent groupings without overwhelming the arrangement. Like many small Cotyledon varieties, it’s easy to maintain as long as it is kept dry, well-lit, and protected from cold.
-
Prefers bright, indirect light or gentle morning sun. Harsh afternoon light in hot climates can cause leaf scorching.
Water when the soil is completely dry, then water deeply and let it drain fully. Overwatering easily leads to rot due to its thick, moisture-retentive leaves.
Adapts well to low indoor humidity. High humidity environments can encourage fungal problems if airflow is poor.
Grows best between 60–80°F. It should be protected from frost and cold drafts, as freezing temperatures can permanently damage the plant.
Requires a gritty, fast-draining soil mix, such as cactus or succulent soil with added sand or perlite. Good drainage is critical to prevent water buildup at the roots.
Feed once or twice during the growing season with a diluted, low-nitrogen fertilizer. Avoid heavy feeding, which can encourage weak, leggy growth.
Cotyledon species are toxic if ingested by pets and humans, potentially causing serious illness. Keep out of reach of children and animals.
- Zone 9-11
Shipping Notes
- Free Standard Shipping on $100+ Orders to the USA.
- Except Preorder products are shipped in 48 hours.
- Delivery to the USA:
- Standard Shipping : 3-10 business days
- If time is of the essence, please consider selecting expedited delivery for faster service.
Exchange/Return Notes
- We offer a 30-day return/exchange service after receiving.
- Final sale items are not eligible for returns or exchanges.
- To process your return/exchange, please contact us at [email protected]
- Please click here for more details>>> Return & Exchange Policy
4.7 ★★★★★
Based on 779 reviews
Sort
Product Reviews
★★★★★ 3
3.5 Stars -- Sturdy but Limited
Color: Purple, Size: Large (Pack of 1)
I got the Barnacle toy in size Large for my ~45 lb mutt. She enjoys food toys, and I wanted to find one sturdy enough that I felt safe leaving her with when I left for work since she tends to destroy her toys quickly.
First thing -- there's no way any dog is going to be able to destroy this. The "rubber" is super thick and a good balance of flexible and sturdy, so she can't do her favorite "pick at a weak edge and slowly disembowel it" trick. I've had it for a couple months now and it looks brand new.
However, it isn't great for feeding her kibble. She eats 1 cup at morning and at night, and none of the compartments fits that comfortably. I don't really feel like dividing her food into 3 portions every day to split it between either. The bigger problem is the hole size, or rather the ratio of kibble-to-hole size. The holes are very big with rubber "fingers" inside to slow the food spill. I've still found that it tends to dump a fistful of kibble all at once, or not let anything go for a long time. This may have to do with my dog's "technique", as described below.
Another problem is that since this has three separate chambers, this toy is not hollow and is surprisingly heavy. While my dog has no problems throwing a kong around (and I mean THROWING a kong around), the weight and asymmetrical shape makes it difficult to throw or roll, which is my dog's preferred way to use a food toy. This toy works best when a dog slaps it with her paws or picks it up and drops it, which may be why my dog gets frustrated with getting her food from it.
What this toy is really great for, for us, is high value treats. If I am leaving at an unusual time and anticipate that she's going to fuss, I can put "the good stuff" in this toy and then she doesn't mind the struggle at all! The different size chambers make this especially nice if I'm breaking up odd sized or home made treats and want her to stay busy for a while. Since it's so sturdy, she can chew on it all she wants, but she has to do the work to get the treats.
All in all-- this toy isn't great for my dog's daily feedings, but it's great for high value treats and a change of pace.
WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare
Reviewed in the United States on March 2, 2015
★★★★★ 5
Actually a challenge for my genius dog!
Color: Purple, Size: Large (Pack of 1)
I am pretty sure my dog owns every puzzle toy and treat-dispensing dog toy that exists, and he's able to figure most of them out in less than 5 minutes. Many last no more than 60 seconds before he's solved them.
The Barncle, however, is actually a challenge for him!
The Barnacle has three "compartments, " none of which are connected. All three have a rubber "mouth" that helps keep treats inside. The rubber "mouth parts" are very effective and make it quite challenging to get treats out once they've been placed inside. You can trim the rubber "mouth parts" to make it easier to let treats out, but I'm not doing that. I'm glad that it's not challenge!
The Barnacle keeps my dog occupied for at least 30 minutes, which is a LONG time for my dog who usually has a "What next?" attitude towards toys.
Th only "bad" thing about the Barnacle is that it's so hard to get treats out of, even for humans. Therefore, it could attract vermin if you're not careful to clean it out.
WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare
Reviewed in the United States on May 20, 2025
★★★★★ 1
OMG - DO NOT BUY - it smells like noxious poison.
Color: Purple, Size: Medium (Pack of 1), Color: Purple, Size: Medium (Pack of 1)
OMG DO NOT BUY!!!!!!!!!!! I didn’t think the reviews stating the noxious smell could be accurate - OMG OUR WHOLE HOUSE REEKS OF POISON. I LITERALLY FEEL LIKE I MAY BE SICK. OMG OMG OMG.
WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare
Reviewed in the United States on April 11, 2026
★★★★★ 5
Great toy for dispensing dinner!
Color: Purple, Size: Large (Pack of 1)
This is one of my puppy's favorite toys! We always try to use toys to dispense his meals, but many of them become too easy for him. Kongs take no time at all to empty. This one seems to provide much more of a challenge, mostly due to the three different sizes of compartments and openings. He'll empty the largest compartment fairly quickly, but the small one almost always has a piece or two of kibble that he just can't get out. This helps to keep him interested in the toy throughout the day.
We use a large breed dog food with larger sized kibble which helps to add to the challenge. The fact that this bounces erratically and doesn't roll smoothly makes it difficult for my dog to develop a method for emptying it quickly. With some other toys, like the Kong Wobbler, he quickly learns to just push it around with his nose. This toy makes him work much harder!
The construction of this toy is very sturdy. We usually feed one meal a day in this, and it's held up well to heavy chewing. I (and my roommates) appreciate that it's made of softer plastic which doesn't make as much noise on the hardwood floors as some of his other toys. The prongs on the openings can be cut to adjust the difficulty, which is nice if you're using different sized kibble or treats. It is a little harder to fill than other toys, but still not terribly difficult.
Overall I've had a great experience with all the PetSafe toys I've tried, and this one is one of the very best!
WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare
Reviewed in the United States on January 11, 2015
★★★★★ 5
Not for dogs that chew/ Update Seller Stands Behind their Product
Color: Con Leche
My 15 pound cavalier spaniel was in love with this toy, but it only took her about an hour to rip the end of it off and expose the contents. We had to take it away from her to prevent her from eating the inside. It might be good for a dog who only wants to play tug-of-war and not chew -wanted to send it back, but it was destroyed so we threw it in the trash. / As a update, I should have read the reviews and this is not for heavy chewers, I will say the seller was awesome and compensated me for this, thank you Olly!
WAS THIS REVIEW HELPFUL?YesReportShare
Reviewed in the United States on January 13, 2026